Cale Dutter

Born and raised in Eau Claire, Wisconsin, Cale attended Eau Claire North High and then the University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire, graduating with a bachelor’s degree in finance in 2017.

After graduation, Cale started his insurance career with the Indianhead Insurance Agency in Eau Claire. In early 2018, Indianhead was absorbed by Ansay & Associates, where Cale continued to work as an Agent until the summer of 2026. Finally, in September 2026, Cale joined the Strobel Insurance Agency.

Cale specializes in both personal and commercial insurance, working alongside individuals and businesses to craft insurance programs tailored to their needs.

Outside of work, Cale enjoys hunting, golf, and a love of history. Cale met his wife Amy in 2022 on a blind date, and the two were married in 2025, recently celebrating their first wedding anniversary.

Contact Information

Office: 715-835-8030
Email: Cale@Strobelinsurance.net

Based on 86 reviews

2 months ago

Jessica has and always will be available to help out with your insurance needs. Thank you Strobel Insurance for your excellent support and service.

angie K.

3 months ago

been with Dave and staff for about 6 years now and wouldn't go any where else highly recommend 👌

Teresa Z.

3 months ago

Strobel insurance is an Amazing company. We ran into a legal matter and Strobel insurance made my experience so comforting and stress free that I recommend them to everyone.

Richard S.

3 months ago

Love working with this firm. Always very helpful and supportive. People are always friendly and supportive.

Dave S.

3 months ago

Extremely professional and friendly agency. Eric is our agent and highly recommend him.

Michelle K.

9 months ago

Jessica was very professional, knowledgeable and friendly. She looked over my old policy and was able to get me better coverage and cheaper than what I was paying with my current provider. I highly recommend her and your company. So happy I made the switch.

Bonnie G.

10 months ago

Dave, Eric and staff are always great to work with. They Respond to questions and requests promptly. When needed, our insurance claims have been taken care of with care of to our satisfaction. Thanks Strobel Insurance!

Mark P.

11 months ago

We have been using the Strobel agency for many years now for all our home and auto needs. Their support when needed has always been friendly, prompt and professional. Most recently we had hail damage to our roof and they provided immediate access to our insurance company adjuster to have the repair work approved. They also kept tabs on the progress throughout the project, which was much appreciated. Highly recommended.

Patrick L.

11 months ago

Strobel Insurance, my long time insurance provider did another solid effort to help provide a path to make repairs on my home related to storm/hail damage that occured earlier this spring. Provided an insurance credit as well.

Carol H.

12 months ago

We have used Strobel Insurance for years and found the company to be professional, polite and accessible for all information. We are insured with Acuity and after the recent hail storm our roof, skylights and gutter helmets were replaced with no issues. Acuity was so easy to work with and I highly recommend them. Dave and the team at Strobel Insurance are #1. Cross your fingers we never have another Hail Storm in Eau Claire.

Michael M.

1 year ago

Strobel Insurance and Acuity were there for me after the storm damage in May. Even when the adjuster missed some items there was never a question about covering it. Excellent service!

J P.

1 year ago

I used Strobel Insurance for years for personal and business needs and was always satisfied with the honesty & attention to my needs. I then moved out of state, and returned a few years ago. My out of state broker offered to continue coverage but I wanted to check with Dave & his team first. After learning that I'd pay $55 a month LESS for the same exact coverage, I switched back to Strobel Insurance. I've gotten the same excellent service as before and I'm happy to work with locals who know me and who have an office thats easily accessible, unlike a lot of the big boys. I'll stick with my hometown team!

Kevin C.

2 years ago

My first contact with Strobel Insurance was with Nancy Hoffmeister. I was looking for policies on a condo, autos and an umbrella. She was clear, concise and professional. First impressions are important I look forward to meeting the rest of the staff and doing business with them. Kevin C

Donna K.

2 years ago

After spending 45 minutes on the phone, with an agent, I was told I would hear back in two days. Called back after 4 days and they said it would take 2 weeks. Mind you this is for an estimate on car insurance! This is what they supposedly do. Well anyway, two weeks passed and nothing, nada, zero, zilch. Disrespectful. Unprofessional. Unfortunate. Would not recommend. Must not need business.

Chenise A.

2 years ago

Had strobel as my agent for over 3 years. Customer Service was terrible. Took 200 days to decide if my vehicle was going to be fixed or totaled out. My coverage got dropped and they couldn't even reach out to let me know.

Michael J.

2 years ago

The customer service at Strobel Insurance is second to none. They take the time to understand my needs and provide clear and detailed explanations, ensuring that I am fully informed and protected.

Lisa S.

3 years ago

I had a wonderful experience with Strobel Insurance Agency:)

Troy K.

3 years ago

Good company to do business with.

Tmg R.

3 years ago

recommends

They are fast, efficient and have great rates! I highly recommend them!

Mark G.

4 years ago

I've been a customer for over ten years and they have the finest customer service that I have experienced. DaLonna is the best insurance agency manager in the business!

Darren M.

5 years ago

Very knowledgeable and great to work with!

Kim P.

5 years ago

We have used Strobel Insurance for years and are very happy with the service we receive. Their office manager DaLonna, is always prompt and willing to help in any way they can. She is willing to answer any question, and they always look for the best rates. Highly recommend Strobel Insurance.

Lorraine D.

5 years ago

We have always received great customer service through Strobel Insurance for both our vehicle or life insurance needs. Even when we had moved back to Canada they were still willing to assist us with our transitional needs. We highly recommend their services, and the fact that they represent a range of services and various insurance companies.